255 Whitney Avenue

East Rock, New Haven, CT 06511

Landlord: Hadley Inc.
4.7

1 review

Building details

Units reviewed (1 unit)

2 bedrooms

1 review

4.7

100% recommend

old building, but below average rent

4.7 overall
Unit: 4.4 Building: 5.0 Landlord: 5.0

2 bedrooms

Summer 2025 ยท 2026

Within the last year

$1,750/mo

kinda hate that im moving out of this place because 1. its relatively cheap 2. in a great area 3. a decent landlord this building is old and that's evident. kitchen is incredibly tiny galley kitchen with a smaller than average stove/oven and refrigerator. heat is included in rent, and it gets TOASTY in the winter. The rent was only increased by $75 on the renewal. The building is quiet and mostly Yale grad students. There is ongoing construction across the street that does tend to go late until 11 pm some nights and is constant all day, very noisy if you WFH. building does have mice problems, but you can get a cat to fix that!

2 beds 1 bath 800 sq ft

Unit Condition

4.4
Structure * 4/5
Plumbing * 5/5
Electrical 5/5
Climate control * 5/5
Ventilation 4/5
Pest control * 3/5
Mold and moisture * 4/5
Appliances 5/5
Layout 5/5
As advertised 5/5

Building

5.0
Common areas 5/5
Security * 5/5
Exterior 5/5
Neighbor noise 5/5
External noise 5/5
Mail and packages 5/5
Laundry 5/5
Parking Not rated
Trash 5/5

Landlord

5.0
Maintenance 5/5
Communication 5/5
Professionalism 5/5
Lease clarity 5/5
Privacy respect 5/5
Deposit handling Not rated
Rent practices 5/5
Non-retaliation 5/5

* Health and safety weighted. These factors count more in the overall score. Learn more

Utilities Included

Heat Hot water Water Trash

Amenities

Storage Elevator Pet friendly
Laundry: Coin-Op ($2/load) Parking: Available (Extra)
Pets allowed: Dogs Small Animals Cats
Section 8: Accepted Well lit at night
Would recommend Email verified

These reviews are written by tenants who lived in the building. We check reviews against our guidelines but can't verify every detail. Terms of service

Rating breakdown

4.4
Unit quality
5.0
Building
5.0
Landlord
Would recommend 100%

Scores are weighted by health and safety factors. Newer reviews count more than older ones. Learn more

Common issues reported

No issues reported